Black October Made Attack Path Management a “Now” Problem

Author

Justin Kohler

Read Time

7 mins

Published

Nov 17, 2026

Share

On the November 10, 2026, Patch Tuesday, Microsoft released fixes for 1,093 vulnerabilities, its second Patch Tuesday in a row with a four-digit count. Sixty-three are rated critical. Attackers are already exploiting one of them. Dustin Childs of the Zero Day Initiative flagged 30 as potentially wormable.

The same day, Gartner published a special report [login required] arguing that “Black October” is the new normal. According to Gartner, any one of October’s major incidents would likely have been the worst of a typical year.

  • PHP2Shell memory leaks forced U.S. and EU government websites offline.
  • Attackers breached commercial refrigeration portals in Europe, causing fires and facility shutdowns.
  • Attackers moved about $6.3 billion out of Binance hot wallets across ten blockchains, most of it in roughly 20 minutes. Binance’s early investigation suggests the attack may have started with a compromised engineer’s laptop.
  • Using the agentic AI framework ARTEX and stolen ConnectWise application credentials, Storm-0940 attempted sign-ins to more than 2,250 Microsoft 365 tenants, reaching privileged access in some in under three hours.

Vulnerability deep dive: Signed, Sealed, and Relayed, NTLM-style: Bypassing LDAP Signing Through Reauthentication

According to Gartner, disclosed vulnerabilities reached nearly 49,000 in 2025, and the firm expects more than 70,000 this year. The industry’s average time to remediate sits at 43 days. At that pace, this week’s fixes would close out around December 23, more than two weeks after December’s Patch Tuesday. AI is surfacing vulnerabilities faster than anyone can patch them, and it’s putting working exploits in the hands of attackers at every skill level. Gartner’s conclusion is that fixing CVEs one at a time is already impractical and that security programs have to become preemptive.

STAY TUNED: We’ll share dates for a webinar series exploring how AI-accelerated vulnerability discovery and exploitation are changing cybersecurity, and how defenders can adapt.

Attack path management belongs in “Now”

Attack paths are chains of identities, privileges, and misconfigurations that let an attacker move from an initial foothold to critical assets. Attack path management (APM) is the practice of finding those chains and breaking them, starting with the choke points where one fix closes the most paths. It complements vulnerability management by showing which weaknesses lead to something that matters.

Gartner advises security and IT leaders to make the move from reactive to preemptive in phases. The first phase, “Now,” focuses on optimizing existing controls and strengthening cyber hygiene: securing the identity fabric, eliminating standing privilege, and reducing technical debt. The second, “Next,” shifts from CVE prioritization to attack path management. Attack path analysis helps teams prioritize the “Now” work: which standing privileges, trust relationships, and legacy exposures put critical assets most at risk?

Every organization I talk to has more identity hygiene debt than it can pay down in a year. Zero standing privilege is the right goal, but a tiny fraction of organizations have achieved it. The practical question is what privileges, on which identities, to fix first. Without a graph of an attacker’s paths, teams answer it with gut feel or tribal knowledge. With the graph, defenders can see that removing one group membership or one misconfigured delegation collapses thousands of paths at once. We call those choke points, and they’re where hygiene work pays off fastest. BloodHound Enterprise’s job is to eliminate paths to critical identities and resources, regardless of how the attacker got in.

Gartner also recommends measuring security performance by attack paths eliminated instead of vulnerability counts. That has been the core idea behind the BloodHound Enterprise release in 2021. As Microsoft’s John Lambert wrote in 2015, defenders think in lists while attackers think in graphs. BloodHound Enterprise handed defenders back control by tailoring the attack graph to focus on those choke points that remove millions of paths at once. We need to be measuring the reduced exposure of critical assets, not just the count of findings closed.

Why attack path management can’t wait

ARTEX illustrates why the connections between exposures matter. In the ARTEX campaign, Storm-0940, a China-aligned actor, took over the cloud identities of ConnectWise’s Cloud Backup applications. Customers had already granted those applications privileged access to their Microsoft 365 tenants, so the attacker could sign in as a trusted app without a user sign-in. Using the agentic AI framework ARTEX, it attempted that access against more than 2,250 tenants and, in some, reached privileged access in under three hours. A backup application with broad tenant permissions is a familiar finding. Once its credentials were stolen, it became a path into every tenant that trusted it.

November’s Patch Tuesday vulnerabilities illustrate the same need to consider downstream access. Microsoft rates the actively exploited Outlook zero-day, CVE-2026-124194, Moderate, with a CVSS score of 6.5. It can expose NTLM authentication material, creating opportunities for credential abuse beyond Outlook. The critical Exchange Server RCE, CVE-2026-118207, requires a low-privilege login. A compromised Exchange server can expose more than mailboxes when it holds broad rights in Active Directory. The Windows LDAP RCE, CVE-2026-119958, requires no authentication, and Childs warned it could be especially destructive on domain controllers.

These vulnerabilities offer different routes into or through an environment. Their consequences depend on both the exploit and what the compromised identity or system can reach. The same Exchange exploit can be a contained incident in one environment and a path to control plane compromise in another, depending on the rights that server holds. Gartner lists this as the second of six structural realities from Black October: exposure outweighs isolated CVE severity.

Where to begin? Internet exposure and active exploitation remain essential prioritization signals. Attack path analysis adds another: what the attacker can reach post-compromise.

Combine those signals to identify vulnerable systems that can reach critical assets and the changes that most reduce that exposure. Start mapping attack paths now and use the map to prioritize hygiene work.

AI agents belong on the same map

Gartner’s identity data points in the same direction. In the surveys cited by Gartner, only 21% of organizations had created an AI agent governance framework, and 50% lacked defined operational boundaries for agents or relied on predefined human access. AI agents operate through identities and credentials, sometimes shared with people or other workloads. Those access relationships can become part of an attack path.

With OpenGraph, teams can extend BloodHound Enterprise beyond Active Directory and Entra ID to model relationships across platforms such as Okta, GitHub, and Jamf. Attack paths cross product boundaries. The identities used by service accounts and AI agents belong on the same map as your control plane admins. If one of them can reach your most critical assets, find that path before an attacker does.

What preemptive means in practice

For an attack path management program, preemptive means putting five practices into operation:

  1. Identify your critical assets.
  2. Continuously track which identities can reach your most critical assets.
  3. Prioritize the fixes that most reduce exposure to critical assets with the least operational disruption.
  4. Report progress in a metric a board understands: how far exposure to critical assets went down.
  5. Run that cycle at the pace of environment change, but at least daily.

Gartner calls the attacker-defender capability gap permanent. The attacker is going to retain the upper hand if we don’t change our programs, not just to keep pace, but to fundamentally disrupt this advantage. Attackers only win when they understand the relationships in an environment better than defenders. However, the defender can proactively map and remove attack paths before the breach takes place.

Black October won’t be the last month like it. Teams that already understand their attack paths can act on the exposures that matter most before the next incident begins.

Justin Kohler

Chief Product Officer

Justin Kohler is Chief Product Officer at SpecterOps, leading BloodHound and other security products. With 15+ years in product and security, he’s led teams at Gigamon, ICEBRG, and Microsoft, and served as a U.S. Air Force cryptologic linguist.

Ready to get started?

Book a Demo